At a hastily scheduled virtual meeting on Wednesday at 7 p.m., the Northampton Community Preservation Act Committee will decide whether to award $500,000 to the O’Connell Development Group to repair the exterior of the St. John Cantius Church on Hawley Street. These repairs are needed so that O’Connell Development can develop multifamily condominiums within the structure.
The next step will be the authorization of the property tax surcharge and matching state tax funds by the City Council to pay out the grant funds. Commonly, council approval of the CPA Committee grant decisions is perfunctory.
I have always supported the CPA program’s mission to finance affordable housing, open space preservation, outdoor recreation or historic preservation. CPA funds are not for delayed maintenance. They should not subsidize an inflationary high-end housing bubble or help gentrify a mixed-income neighborhood.
When O’Connell Development bought St. John Cantius in 2020, they must have known that the building was of historical significance and cherished by the community. They were also surely aware that the church, decommissioned in 2010, had no significant maintenance subsequently. Since buying the property, O’Connell Development has demolished the other church buildings and are currently building 23 condominiums.
They now say they will invest $4 million more to build 10 units within the St. John Cantius building to construct the only type of housing not in critically short supply in Northampton. At $450 a square foot, a 1,700-square-foot unit would sell for more than $700,000. At that rate, O’Connell Development would leave with $7 million after these are sold. These figures are based on real estate listings for condos currently for sale in Northampton, and on the size of condos being building on Hawley Street.
The overwhelming majority of applicants for CPA grants is nonprofits. These organizations, by statute, reveal their financial information, as a matter of public record.
In contrast, O’Connell Development’s assertions to the committee regarding their project’s “financial feasibility ” and “market forces” are unverifiable by the committee. Supporting information is considered to be private or proprietary.
The applicant has repeatedly threatened to demolish this cherished, historically significant building. Their continually evolving plans were brought to multiple city committees and boards, exhausting the staff and volunteers that serve on them. Previously, O’Connell Development had promised, and then abandoned, their plan to preserve the church as a restaurant or entertainment center, due to unverifiable “market forces.”
The applicant has rejected the city’s offer to buy the church at 40% of their original investment, claiming that a city-run Community Resiliency Hub would be “out of keeping with the character of the Philips Place” neighborhood, where they have so recently arrived. Their nearest neighbor is the post office.
The applicant’s most recent plan is to “restore” the exterior, allowing the subsidizing taxpayer to enjoy the church building from a distance. They recently claim that unverifiable “high costs and supply chain problems” may necessitate replacing the church’s red tile roof with red shingles. The already built tall, bland condominiums clash with and dwarf the church’s exterior. It is very difficult to photograph the fine architecture with the current project.
Other older 19th century Catholic churches were also decommissioned by the Diocese in 2010. These other architectural gems are also cherished by our immigrant ancestors and the present-day Northampton community. Happily, Blessed Sacrament Church (I got married there in 1978) was recently purchased and is being repaired and restored at the expense of the new owners, with no public funds.
The largest and oldest, St. Mary’s of the Assumption Church, was the site of many religious and community events. It stands on the market, crumbling at the opposite end of Main Street with no public funds to maintain or restore it.
The Friends of St. John Cantius have organized a publicity campaign to support this CPA application. Notably, the campaign does not include fund raising to give O’Connell Development the money to preserve the structure. A false belief has developed that those who criticize the development group’s CPA application are disrespectful of the beloved church structure.
I remain hopeful the committee action will be consistent with the spirit of the CPA. Other pressing community needs in the CPA Committee’s wheelhouse include the proposed, sorely needed 124 affordable housing units on Bridge Road. In the same grant cycle, this project received only $600,000.
The mandated Northampton Housing Trust for affordable housing has never received CPA funds. The Planning Department and the mayor can’t currently fund the development of swimming areas for outdoor recreation.
Approving this grant will produce unintended consequences inconsistent with the CPA’s core mission. I believe it will set a future precedent, establishing an incorrect template for CPA grant applications from for-profit organizations.
Brigid Glackin lives in Florence.
