Daily Hampshire Gazette - Established 1786
Cloudy
67°
Cloudy
Hi 69° | Lo 56°

Michael Engel: Outraged by proposal from self-appointed guardians of the oppressed

To the editor:

I consider myself politically a person of the left. And I have always resented the phrase “political correctness” as it is thrown at us by those on the right to justify their racism.

But I have always been annoyed by the endless stream of initiatives to “ban this” and “ban that” coming from certain citizens of Amherst. It is made even more unpalatable by the smug, arrogant and self-righteous “progressive” rhetoric always accompanying those proposals.

The latest and perhaps the worst is the call to deport “Tintin,” that alleged agent of imperialism, to a corner of the local library where his adventures will not taint the innocent minds of children.

As a former owner of Cherry Picked Books in Easthampton, and having recently opened a children’s used bookstore in Ludlow, the alarm bells go off whenever I hear about censorship.

So I am outraged by this proposal from some self-appointed guardians of the oppressed, and especially because it comes from my own side of the political fence.

That they cravenly sugar-coat this as a “principled middle ground” and an attempt to promote “conversation” is nothing but hypocrisy. Censorship is censorship.

I have a couple of the “Tintin” books in stock; I also had them in my old bookstore. Would the “Amherst Thought Police” suggest that I now put them in a far corner with a sign saying “Imperialism is bad for your mental health?”

Or should I go all the way and burn them on the sidewalk outside — perhaps along with my “Babar the Elephant” books — as a symbol of my commitment to ending imperialism and racism?

I commend the board of the Jones Library for rejecting this suggestion, and standing up for what librarians have always courageously defended against those who would impose their politics on the rest of us: The right to freely choose what we read.

Michael Engel

Southampton

Related

‘Tintin’ comics to remain in Amherst library children’s room despite parents’ objections

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

AMHERST — A graphic novel series containing racial stereotypes that some parents argue is inappropriate for pre-teens will not be removed from the children’s area at the Jones Library as a group has requested. But library officials are pledging to be part of a community dialogue focused on racial issues and to better inform the public about the children’s room … 8

Bill Massey: Takes letter writer to task for comment about political correctness

Monday, January 6, 2014

To the editor; I consider myself a reasonable person with respect for all, even those who disagree with me or my choices and preferences. I do, however, lose respect for those who choose to use inappropriate labels in a broad manner unjustly, such as a recent letter writer when he wrote that the term political correctness is “thrown at us … 0

There are no comments yet. Be the first!
Post a Comment

You must be registered to comment on stories. Click here to register.