Daily Hampshire Gazette - Established 1786
Hi 39° | Lo 20°

Northampton mayor orders benches back on Main Street 

  • Pedestrians share a sidewalk on Main Street in downtown Northampton on Wednesday morning.
  • Main Street, Northampton, Tuesday morning, May 29, 2013.<br/>KEVIN GUTTING
  • Main Street, Northampton, Tuesday morning, May 29, 2013.<br/>KEVIN GUTTING

Plenty of cities and towns around the country have done the same to eliminate nuisance behaviors in public spaces, from Harvey Milk Plaza in San Francisco to Selby Five Points Park in downtown Sarasota, Fla.

Closer to home, consider Greenfield, where former Mayor Christine Forgey authorized the removal of several downtown benches during her first term in office seven years ago. Forgey weathered criticism at the time, but some of the benches have never been replaced.

“It was a hard call because there were lots of people who were saying ‘It’s the wrong the thing to do,’ and businesses who where saying ‘Thank you,’” Forgey recalled. “I do think it was effective.”

The move came as merchants were lodging complaints with City Hall about people monopolizing downtown benches, particularly near the intersection of Main and Federal streets. Panhandling, public intoxication, loitering, and use of offensive street language were among the issues cited by business owners.

“They felt like it was a detriment to their business, that it would deter people from going into their businesses,” Forgey said. “Quite honestly, there were issues and a lot of public nuisance calls to that area.”

Forgey said the removal of benches in Greenfield came as the city was attempting to revitalize its downtown. In her view, the nuisance behavior around the benches, while reflective of wider social problems, became unacceptable for the downtown.

“We did what we had to do,” Forgey said. “I would stand by my decision way back then given the context of the time.”

During the past year, Greenfield has been installing new benches in different locations downtown, such as the Town Common, under a new mayor.

Bill Baker, a business owner who for years sought the removal of benches in front of his Main Street store, Baker Office Supply, believes it is a “mistake” to reintroduce the public seating.

“It just breeds issues,” Baker said. “Since they’ve been removed, it’s been a nicer place.”

Baker once had two sets of back-to-back benches in front of his store near the common, which remains a bench-free section of Main Street. A hot-dog vendor now occupies space nearby with a table and a few chairs, making for a more amicable environment, he said.

“I’ve requested that they never be replaced,” he said of the benches.

Planning perspectives

According to some urban landscape experts, environmental modifications like removing public benches are one of many low-cost tools used to discourage loitering, panhandling and other behaviors that communities find a nuisance.

“It stands to reason that if you make places less comfortable to hang out, you’re going to dissuade people from being there,” said Nancy La Vigne, director of the Urban Institute’s Justice Policy Center in Washington. “I think that removing the benches could well be effective, but it shouldn’t be done as the sole method.”

La Vigne, who has written on panhandling-prevention strategies, said a comprehensive approach is needed to eliminate aggressive panhandling and loitering, which can sometimes lead to crime. Educating the public fits into that equation, she said.

“They are certainly viewed as a public nuisance, but it starts with ‘Who are the panhandlers? Why are they there?’” La Vigne said.

La Vigne said municipalities must also consider what happens next. The removal of benches may be successful at eliminating panhandlers in one area but inadvertently redirect them to another.

“Will they take their panhandling activities with them?” she asked. “That’s open to question.”

Northampton City Planner Wayne M. Feiden said people generally like activity and want to be where the action is in a downtown, which is one reason benches become attractive destinations.

The city has tried, particularly along its rail trail system, to locate benches and granite-block seating areas in places where there is the least likelihood of conflict among people who live near and use the trails.

“My own feeling is, it’s legitimate to think about where benches should go,” he said.

Bench removal projects

As in Northampton, decisions to remove, relocate and reconfigure public benches have stirred significant public debate and backlash in other parts of the country.

In 2011, officials in Santa Barbara, Calif., toyed with a $50,000 plan that involved turning more than a dozen benches on busy State Street perpendicular to storefronts to make it harder for bench-sitters to panhandle. The plan was nixed after a public outcry, according to a report in the Los Angeles Times.

In November, benches were removed in Harvey Milk Plaza in San Francisco’s Castro District to prevent panhandling, public drunkenness and homeless people from sleeping there, according to published reports. The benches were installed only a few years earlier at a cost of tens of thousands of dollars and their removal drew criticism from homeless advocates and others.

The removal and relocation of benches has also occurred in business districts and public spaces in places like Columbia, Mo.; Charlottsville, Va.; and as far afield as Vancouver, British Columbia.

Officials in the Gulf Coast city of Sarasota, Fla., recently removed benches in Selby Five Points Park to deter loiterers and homeless people who officials, merchants and residents in nearby luxury condominiums said had monopolized the seating and essentially cut them off from public use.

“I believe the greater good of the city was held hostage by the homeless who were doing everything just short of lodging on these benches,” said former Mayor Suzanne Atwell, now a city commissioner. “They had a monopoly. They (the benches) were abused.”

Atwell recalled the harsh criticism commissioners took when they voted to remove the benches in 2011. The city saw protests in the park, not unlike the bench-removal protest in downtown Northampton last weekend.

But, she noted, life has changed “dramatically” around the park since the benches were eliminated.

“This was not about civil rights, it was about behavior,” said Atwell, whose father grew up in Northampton. “It was a small group of people who took it over. I found it intolerable.”

Atwell noted that in addition to removing benches, Sarasota has enacted anti-panhandling laws to prevent panhandlers from soliciting for cash in the middle of roads, among other measures.

In 2009, former Northampton Mayor Clare Higgins floated a solicitation ordinance co-sponsored by the city’s police chief that sought to regulate panhandling activities, but it was tabled indefinitely after a public outcry.

In Atwell’s view, while enacting panhandling laws is part of a larger work in progress, removing the benches in downtown Sarasota improved the quality of life for many in the city.

“It was a tough decision, but I think it was the right decision,” she said. “You have to do something. Somebody has to be brave and make a decision.”

Dan Crowley can be reached at dcrowley@gazettenet.com.


Police walk fine line on panhandling

Wednesday, May 29, 2013

NORTHAMPTON — It falls to local police to protect the rights of panhandlers and pedestrians alike. Northampton’s recent decision to remove benches from downtown in an attempt to curb loitering left some wondering why police were not asked to clear sidewalks and discourage panhandling. The simple answer: In most cases, they can’t. Northampton Police Chief Russell Sienkiewicz said the issue …

Legacy Comments5

How is it that MassLive has 117 comments on the same story and the Gazette has 4? Hmmm. . . . . .

The merchants and the mayor are in a circular firing squad. This publicity spreading far and wide goes to support a growing stereotype that Northampton has lost its charm and its downtown is populated by a harsher environment then the reality. Disorderly conduct should be treated as such, prohibitions and restrictions on blocking door ways should be enforced. This is great publicity for the upcoming "Restaurant Week" event. The other thing is many people can be coopted if approached in the right way. The truth is the country has far more retail space than it needs. The stores downtown cater to selling high end non necessities that in difficult economic times may not be sought by many people.

The mayor caved in too quickly to the power of the disgusting behavior of the panhandlers. Apparently, he does not have the courage to confront all of the issues of panhandling, homelessness, public intoxication, drug use etc. etc. that has turned Northampton streets into an inhospitable city. Make the hard choices for the majority of your taxpayers and merchants like the mayor of Greenfield has done. If you can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen.

As the article points out many towns and cities have implemented similar measures. Narkiewicz's mistake is that he thought he could ram it through without any public dialogue, or any attempt to "sell" the plan to residents. That backfired quickly and badly, and now he is scrambling to reverse himself. His idea may not have been a bad one; it was just terribly executed.

What was the process behind the decision to remove the benches? There was no public input. It seems like the mayor and BID decided the benches would go, and then made it happen. Can they do this? What role if any does the Council, evidently not consulted, play? Narkiewicz moved too quickly on this one, without regard for optics. Good thing he is backing off just as quickly. The article was instructive in laying out the reasons other communities have removed benches. But Northampton is not Sarasota and panhandling is part of street life that people have learned to live with. Some seem to like it and think it gives the town its character. I am ambivalent but think the bench removal was clearly a wrong move. A more surgical approach is needed to deal with problem aspects of panhandling/vagrancy, and the police force plays an important role here.

Post a Comment

You must be registered to comment on stories. Click here to register.