Daily Hampshire Gazette - Established 1786
Clouds and sun
81°
Clouds and sun
Hi 83° | Lo 62°

Forum: Aftermath of the Black Friday protest at Wal-Mart in Hadley

  • JERREY ROBERTS<br/>Marjorie Ewing, front left, of Belchertown, takes part in a rally for workers' rights and a protest of Wal-Mart Nov. 29 in Hadley.
  • Walmart logo.  (PRNewsFoto/WALMART CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS)

EDITOR’S NOTE: Readers respond to a Dec. 9 letter critical of a protest at the Hadley Wal-Mart.

Studies refute claims on Wal-Mart might

A Dec. 9 letter reveals that the writer did not much like the Wal-Mart protest in Hadley on Black Friday. For starters, he was upset that an elected official joined the protest, and as a retired person, he was embarrassed by the Raging Grannies.

The writer is pleased that Wal-Mart has restored a dead mall to life and he reasons that though he likes mom-and-pop stores, he doesn’t think they could generate enough revenue to keep our “government’s spend-and-waste policies alive.” Sounds sort of reasonable, but sometimes intuition fails us — a little Googling might cast a different light on the subject. A 2008 study published in the Journal of Economics looked at 3,000 Wal-Mart store openings nationally. The study found, on average, that a store opening resulted in a county-level net decline of 150 jobs, as it forced other businesses to downsize or shutter. In 2010, 1.4 million Americans worked at Wal-Mart. The average associate earned $8.87 an hour, or $15,700 a year for a 34-hour week (assuming a 52-week year). For a family of three, this is fully $3,000 below the poverty line. Wal-Mart earned a net profit in 2011 of $15.7 billion. Were Wal-Mart to raise wages by $2.13 an hour, bringing average hourly pay to $11 an hour, it could just manage to push salaries up to the poverty line.

And Wal-Mart would still have earned net profits of $10.4 billion. The rest of us, including the letter-writer, are also stakeholders. A Wisconsin study found that a single 300-person Wal-Mart store likely costs taxpayers more than $900,000 a year in Medicaid and food stamps to help Wal-Mart employees get by. Just six members of the Walton family have amassed an estimated combined fortune of between $115 billion and $144 billion. These six individuals have more wealth than the combined financial assets of the poorest 40 percent of the U.S. population.

Perhaps the writer might undertake a rethink — and join the next Wal-Mart demo.

Ernest Urvater

Amherst

Lawmaker correct to attend this event

In a Dec. 9 letter in the Gazette about the recent demonstration at the Hadley Wal-Mart at which Ellen Story spoke, the writer asks, “Since when do we have an elected official out in public rallying against a business like Wal-Mart?” One answer is, since the days of Theodore Roosevelt, who vociferously criticized trusts and other Gilded Age manipulators of employment and wealth in this country.

Another answer is, never before now — because until now there never has been a business like Wal-Mart, employing two million people, earning more than its nine closest competitors combined and putting more than one hundred billion dollars into the bank accounts of a single family whose idea of appreciating their employees’ efforts is to suggest that people who make $11 an hour should donate food to other people who are also making $11 an hour but have more living expenses to manage.

Why shouldn’t our elected leaders speak publicly on behalf of wage earners?

In deriding the workers at Wal-Mart who also participated in the demonstration, the writer implies that if one does not agree with the way one’s business is run, one’s only options are to shut up or to leave. Interestingly, others do not share this view.

Wal-Mart executives have constantly denied that the company ever harasses, ostracizes or fires workers who speak in favor of unionizing. Investigations by the National Labor Relations Board have found that in fact Wal-Mart has done exactly what it claims not to do. Its workers need to say something.

Sell Wal-Mart to the Chinese? Why bother with the formalities? Chinese workers already make most of the goods sold in Wal-Mart stores. As for the writer’s suggestion that there are “no more jobs” in America, unemployment in this country has been dropping steadily for the past year.

And about the Raging Grannies: I’m sorry they embarrass the writer, but I suspect the “old girls” themselves aren’t losing a lot of sleep over that fact.

John Stifler

Florence

This ‘raging granny’ now has her dander up

I am one of those “embarrassing” Raging Grannies referred to in a recent letter to Gazette. We were accused of biting the hand that feeds hundreds of elderly because we often protest against the poor wages Wal-Mart gives its workers. Really? We bite? Well, good for us! Wal-Mart, like the fast food industry, relies on government programs to subsidize the low wages of its employees, while the company itself makes money hand over fist. Those government programs are now being threatened and cut by our Republican-dominated Congress for being too expensive, when in reality all taxpayers, including the elderly, are subsidizing Wal-Mart, which causes more people to use these programs. So I would like to point out to my fellow retiree who criticized us for standing up for the workers, and who likes the cheap food and products at Wal-Mart, that you may be eating cheaply, but you would be wiser if you bought locally. You are putting money in the pockets of millionaires and they don’t live around here.

And yes, I do think mom and pop stores could generate enough revenue, along with medium-sized and far bigger businesses, to keep our town, state and federal governments’ programs alive and well. I appreciate the many services our business taxes support: fire departments, police, schools, libraries, roads and a hand up to those who are in need. And I was proud to see our state representative, Ellen Story, doing her job and supporting higher wages too!

Peggy Anderson

Granby

Related

Noel Gomez: Protest at Hadley Wal-Mart a ‘fiasco’

Friday, December 20, 2013

To the editor: I saw where there was a rally against Wal-Mart over in Hadley Nov. 29. Since when do we have an elected official out in public rallying against a business like Wal-Mart? Why wasn’t she out gathering support for Obamacare and doing her job? Next we have a student organizing this rally who I’m sure doesn’t pay taxes. … 8

Paul Cherulnik: Wal-Mart critics look at wage, fairness issues too narrowly

Friday, December 20, 2013

NORTHAMPTON — It is probably very self-satisfying to carry placards proclaiming that corporations like Wal-Mart are more interested in maximizing their profits than in enhancing the welfare of their employees. And the charge is undoubtedly true. But many protests about corporate greed seem based on little critical thinking and raise as many questions as they answer. Do local businesses treat … 1

Area politicians join Black Friday protest at Hadley Wal-Mart

Friday, December 20, 2013

HADLEY — About 150 people massed outside the Wal-Mart store in Hadley Friday afternoon to protest the company’s labor practices and support the employees inside. The hour-long protest was part of a nationwide campaign on Black Friday, one of the biggest shopping days of the year. Protesters claimed Wal-Mart provides inadequate wages and benefits, unfairly schedules employees’ hours and discourages … 1

There are no comments yet. Be the first!
Post a Comment

You must be registered to comment on stories. Click here to register.